Custom Cakes - Via Online Form

*Applicable to the following MarketPlace Foods stores:

  • Brillion, WI
  • Houghton, MI
  • Iron Mountain, MI
  • Marquette, MI
  • Sturgeon Bay, WI

Need something with a special touch for your upcoming celebration? Order a custom cake from our bakery.

Our cakes are baked fresh for the best flavor and texture. Our decadent buttercream icing melts in your mouth and our cake decorators will create a cake that will have your guests asking for seconds.

Whether you want fun, classic, or elegant we’ll create the perfect cake for you!

From crazy, comic and colorful…to soft, subtle and sentimental…Our award winning bakers and decorators are ready to dazzle you with exceptional service and quality.


What to know when ordering a cake:
We appreciate 48 hours notice to make sure you get exactly the cake you want. To avoid any confusion or missing orders please place the the order at the store you wish to pick up your cake. How many servings do you need? If you’re unsure, see our helpful Party Planner or use the image below to decide.

Party Planner - Tadych's Custom Cakes

Our available cake flavors are White, Chocolate, 1/2 White & 1/2 Chocolate, Marble, Poppyseed, Confetti, Carrot, Strawberry and Raspberry.

Our available icing types are Bettercreme (whipped light & smooth), Old Fashioned Buttercream (rich & creamy) and Cream Cheese. Our available icing flavors are Vanilla and Chocolate.

Decorations:
Your cake should be as unique as you! Whether you want an edible image; iced flowers or balloons; drawn image; or a toy kit our decorators are here to help you pick the perfect cake.

Colors:
We have a wide variety of colors to choose from for your icing selection. School colors are often popular for graduation cakes.

PhotoCake Images:
Get your child’s favorite character printed on your cake as well as fun seasonal images, sports themes, and more! We partner with PhotoCake to provide images perfect for every occasion. Pick out your image online and order your cake online below and specify the image you’d like or visit your local Tadych’s bakery to speak with one of our decorators!

Edible Image Requirements:
Original photos need to be a minimum size of 4×6″. Cream cheese icing is not recommended for edible images. The photo is much clearer on white icing. Copyright laws limit images that can be photo copied onto the cake. Discuss with decorator to make sure your picture can be legally copied.

Inscriptions:
If you want to have an inscription on your cake please have your wording ready-a typed copy is appreciated!

Edible Images:
Have a photo printed on your cake.

Our bakeries are open Monday through Saturday 7am to 5pm and Sundays 7am to 2pm. Stop in anytime and speak to one of our associates to order your cake.

If you’d rather order over the phone please find your local store’s number on our locations page and ask to speak to someone in our bakery department.

You can also use the form below and order your cake online!

Fill out my online form.
Back to Top